With a hail-damaged roof, filing a claim usually makes sense when the repair costs clearly more than your deductible and you plan to stay or fix the house before selling. Selling as-is can make sense when the deductible is as large as the repair, or larger, so a claim would pay nothing, or when you’d rather not manage a repair. Start with your policy’s declarations page, then do the math.
This article shares general information about Texas homeowners insurance and selling. It isn’t legal or insurance advice; your policy, your insurance company and your agent have the final word.
Start with your declarations page
Before you decide anything, pull out your policy. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) explains in Replacement cost or actual cash value: “The first page of your policy is the declarations page. It has a summary of your policy, including your coverages, dollar limits, and deductibles.”
TDI’s roof tips add one more thing to check: “Ask your agent if the deductible for wind and hail damage is different than the deductible for other types of damages.”
Do the deductible math
TDI’s page on deductibles starts with the basics: “A deductible may be a specific dollar amount or a percentage.” A percentage deductible is figured from the home’s insured value, not set as a flat dollar amount.
TDI’s examples use “homes insured for $150,000.” One of them reads: “Policy B has a 5 percent deductible – or $7,500. If the home needed $6,500 in roof repairs, Policy B would not pay anything because the amount of repairs is less than the deductible.”
Two more points from TDI are good to keep in mind. “For home and auto policies, the deductible will be applied to each claim.” And: “Remember that filing small claims may affect how much you have to pay for insurance later.”
So the first question is a simple one. Does a fair repair estimate come in well above your deductible? If it’s close to the deductible, or below it, a claim may not leave you with much.
Replacement cost or actual cash value?
How your policy pays matters too. TDI says, “Actual cash value coverage pays replacement cost minus depreciation.” Depreciation is the drop in value from wear and age.
TDI walks through a 10-year-old roof. A new roof costs $10,000 today, and the deductible is $2,000. With replacement cost coverage, the company pays $8,000. With actual cash value coverage, the old roof might be valued at $7,000, so after the deductible the company pays $5,000, and the owner covers the rest of the new roof. TDI sums it up: “This means your total out-of-pocket costs for an actual cash value policy would be $5,000, compared with $2,000 for a replacement cost policy.”
Our roof and hail damage page explains how replacement cost payments work.
If you file: TDI’s claim tips
If the math points toward a claim, TDI’s hail and windstorm tips include these steps:
- “Take pictures and video of the damage.”
- “Don’t throw any damaged items away until your insurance company tells you.”
- “Be available for the adjuster visit.”
Our page on selling a house with roof or hail damage covers filing timing and temporary repairs. Our page on selling a fire-damaged house explains insurer deadlines and insurance checks that name your mortgage company.
Choosing who fixes it
Whether you file or not, TDI’s advice on hiring is plain:
- “Get more than one bid or repair estimate.”
- “Don’t pay in full up front.”
- “Never sign a contract that has blank spaces.”
TDI’s page Roofing and insurance: know the law adds: “Texas doesn’t allow a roofer or contractor to act as a public insurance adjuster on insurance claims if they’re also doing the work.” The statute behind it, Insurance Code §4102.163, says, “A contractor may not act as a public adjuster or advertise to adjust claims for any property for which the contractor is providing or may provide contracting services”.
For the rules about roofers and deductibles, see our roof and hail damage page.
If hail hits after you sign a sales contract
The standard Texas resale contract, TREC form 20-19, covers this in paragraph 14: “If any part of the Property is damaged or destroyed by fire or other casualty after the Effective Date of this contract, Seller shall restore the Property to its previous condition as soon as reasonably possible, but in any event by the Closing Date.”
If the seller can’t because of factors beyond the seller’s control, the buyer can end the contract and get the earnest money back, extend the time to perform by up to 15 days, or take the house in its damaged condition with an assignment of insurance proceeds, “if permitted by Seller’s insurance carrier,” plus a credit for the deductible. It’s wise to keep your insurance in force until closing.
Or sell the house as-is
FlipUgly is a family-owned business of The Joyner Company LLC. We don’t list homes for sellers. We buy houses as-is.
If a claim is still open, please ask your insurer and lender how a sale fits with it. We buy the house as-is, whether or not you’ve filed a claim. When we visit, we’ll ask what you know about the house. After we see the property, you get a written, no-obligation cash offer the same day. We can close in 15 days or less, or on a later date you choose. No fee to get an offer, and we’ll never ask you to wire us money.
For what to tell a buyer, see the Texas seller disclosure explained. Our cash offer vs. listing page compares the two paths in general terms.
Frequently asked questions
What is a percentage deductible for hail damage?
It’s a deductible set as a percentage of the home’s insured value instead of a flat dollar amount. In TDI’s example, a 5 percent deductible on a home insured for $150,000 is $7,500, so a $6,500 roof repair would not be paid.
How does actual cash value coverage pay for a hail-damaged roof?
TDI says actual cash value coverage pays replacement cost minus depreciation. In its example of a 10-year-old roof, the owner pays $5,000 out of pocket with actual cash value coverage, compared with $2,000 with replacement cost coverage.
Can my roofer also handle my insurance claim in Texas?
Not as your public adjuster. TDI says Texas doesn’t allow a roofer or contractor to act as a public insurance adjuster on claims if they’re also doing the work, and Insurance Code §4102.163 says the same.
What happens if hail damages the house after I sign a sales contract?
Under the standard Texas resale contract, the seller must restore the property by the closing date. If the seller can’t, the buyer can end the contract, extend closing up to 15 days, or accept the house as-is with an assignment of the insurance proceeds, if the insurer permits it, plus a credit for the deductible.
Can filing a small hail claim affect my insurance costs?
It can. TDI says filing small claims may affect how much you have to pay for insurance later, and the deductible applies to each claim.
Weighing your options?
Weighing a claim against a sale? We’re glad to walk the house with you.
Closing in 15 days or less once title is clear.